True Crime Case Histories

Case 6: The Werewolf Butcher

June 16, 2024 Jason Neal Episode 6
Case 6: The Werewolf Butcher
True Crime Case Histories
More Info
True Crime Case Histories
Case 6: The Werewolf Butcher
Jun 16, 2024 Episode 6
Jason Neal

In 1994, nine-year-old Penny Davis disappeared near her rural home in Okanogan County, Washington. Six months later, her body was found in a shallow grave. The prime suspect was Jack Spillman, who had a criminal history and had dated Penny's mother. In 1995, Spillman brutally murdered Rita Huffman and her fourteen-year-old daughter Amanda in their home in Wenatchee, Washington. Evidence linked Spillman to both crime scenes, and while in prison, he revealed disturbing details about the murders to his cellmate. To avoid the death penalty, Spillman pleaded guilty and was sentenced to life in prison without parole.

For photos pertaining to this case, visit the online appendix at TrueCrimeCaseHistories.com.




For more information on this story and others in the True Crime Case Histories book series, visit us at JasonNealBooks.com or check us out on Amazon.

Show Notes

In 1994, nine-year-old Penny Davis disappeared near her rural home in Okanogan County, Washington. Six months later, her body was found in a shallow grave. The prime suspect was Jack Spillman, who had a criminal history and had dated Penny's mother. In 1995, Spillman brutally murdered Rita Huffman and her fourteen-year-old daughter Amanda in their home in Wenatchee, Washington. Evidence linked Spillman to both crime scenes, and while in prison, he revealed disturbing details about the murders to his cellmate. To avoid the death penalty, Spillman pleaded guilty and was sentenced to life in prison without parole.

For photos pertaining to this case, visit the online appendix at TrueCrimeCaseHistories.com.




For more information on this story and others in the True Crime Case Histories book series, visit us at JasonNealBooks.com or check us out on Amazon.